Covergirl Perfect Point Plus Charcoal Color Eyeliner Pencil, 0.008 Ounce (Pack of 2)

I have been using these for at least 25 years. I get complimented at least once a day by some stranger because they love my eye makeup that's why I keep buying it. They give the perfect edge to every eye.

LOL, how does one really do a review on eye liner? It goes on smooth, color is accurate and stays put all day. Not tear proof, but what is?

I love these eyeliners, but they have discontinued the Gray Khaki color. Bring that back and you'll have a customer for life. Eyeliner pencil with built in blending tip makes it easy to use.

A little too soft, but otherwise good. Too soft makes it hard to get a even line.I like waterproof, my allergies make my eyes water and this eyeliner stays put.

This is my favorite eyeliner. I don’t like dark black as my skin is too light but this charcoal grey color looks better. The smudge part at the other end is another reason it’s my favorite, as it smudges away harsh lines for a more natural look. I’ve been using this for years and although I’ve tried many others, I always go back to this one!

I have used this eyeliner, mostly Black Onyx, for many, many years! It is definitely my go-to product. Before online shopping I would be so upset when the stores would be out of this and I would be forced to use something else. I would always just toss those as soon as I was able to get my hands on this stuff! I love how easily it applies and the built-in smudger. I only have a couple of small points to make about these. First, it says "self-sharpening" but it does not actually sharpen the point. It is just that the surface area is small so it allows for more precise application. Unlike a traditional pencil eyeliner where the surface gets wider as the tip wears down so you need to sharpen it to get the pointed tip back, this always is a "tip" so no need to sharpen. Second, as I said, I have used this product for many, many years. Occasionally, I will receive one of these where the crayon is broken inside the cover, usually into many small pieces. It means that, as applying, the piece will just fall off. It's annoying, messy, and wasteful. But, that being said, it only happens very occasionally. Overall, I still love this eyeliner and I will continue to purchase it!

Love the color, but the retractable eyeliner breaks off easily as you apply it.Does not go on smoothly.

Great price